The quiet signals leaders miss before high performers leave

The quiet signals leaders miss before high performers leave

Over the years, I’ve learned that people don’t always leave an organisation on the day they resign. Often, the decision has been forming quietly for a long time.

Research supports what many leaders see in practice: disengagement usually begins before performance drops.

  • Gallup describes engagement as the psychological attachment people have to their work, their team and their employer.
  • McKinsey’s research on return on talent makes a similar point from a business lens, identifying lack of engagement, skill gaps and low-value work as hidden sources of productivity loss that can remain invisible until they begin showing up as attrition and vacancies.

That is why a resignation can feel sudden to a leader, even when the person has been pulling back internally for months or even longer.

It may begin in the meeting where someone decides it’s no longer worth saying what they really think. It may begin when effort is taken for granted one more time, when growth is delayed because someone is too useful where they are, or when honest disagreement starts feeling unsafe.

From the outside, not much changes at first. The person still attends meetings, completes the work, meets deadlines and remains dependable. But their relationship with the work has started to shift.

Disconnection begins when they participate with more caution than conviction.

The mistake leaders often make is looking only at output. But the problem with looking at output only is that it tells only half the story. Many times output can continue long after connection has started to weaken.

By the time the resignation letter arrives, the leader may feel surprised. But often, the person didn’t leave suddenly. They had been stepping back for a long time.

When Capability Hides Disconnection

High performers can be difficult to read because they often keep going even when they’re depleted. This is part of what makes them valuable. It’s also what makes their disconnection easier to miss.

When someone continues to deliver, we assume they’re fine. But competence can hide what a person is no longer saying.

Great thing about high performers are that they are not complainers. You won't find them saying it out loud the moment they begin to feel overlooked. Or when their ideas feel shut down or their growth feels blocked.

In the beginning, many of them try to adjust. They tell themselves to be patient, to understand the larger picture, to keep doing the responsible thing.

But when the same patterns continue for too long, something changes. They may still care about the work, but they begin protecting themselves from the cost of caring too much in a place where it no longer feels reciprocated.

A Conversation That Stayed With Me

A few weeks ago, I shared an infographic on LinkedIn about 10 leadership habits that quietly push high performers out.

The quiet signals leaders miss before high performers leave

It named patterns many people recognised immediately: good work being rewarded with more work, growth being blocked to retain someone, strong ideas being ignored, constant urgency becoming normal, honest disagreement being punished, and excellence being expected without being truly appreciated.

More than 100K people saw the post, but what stayed with me wasn't the reach. It was the conversation underneath it.

One comment said that resilience should never be mistaken for infinite tolerance. That's an important nuance because high performers often absorb a great deal without visible complaint. Their strength can make them look stable until they’re already close to done.

Another person pointed out that high performers can carry a heavy load, but what often breaks them is watching someone else give far less and receive the same recognition. That distinction matters. Many capable people aren’t afraid of hard work. What affects them is the feeling that effort has become one-sided.

Someone else reminded us that leaders often underestimate what walks out when a strong person leaves.

It isn’t only a role that becomes vacant when a high performer leaves. Context, trust, ownership and organisational memory leave with them.

And one comment asked a question that deserves more attention: What does healthy and effective leadership look like instead?

That is where the deeper work begins. It’s easier to name what pushes good people away. It’s harder to look honestly at what leaders can build before quiet disconnection begins.

The Emotional Contract Breaks Quietly

Every organisation has a formal contract. Role, compensation, responsibilities and expectations are usually clear enough to be written down.

But there is also an emotional contract. It’s rarely stated, but people feel when it’s being honoured and when it’s being ignored. That contract says: if I give my best, it will be valued. If I speak honestly, it will be respected. If I perform, there will be room for me to keep growing. If I carry responsibility, I won’t be taken for granted.

When that contract is healthy, people give more than what's written in their job description. When it begins to break, they usually protect themselves before they leave.

They stop offering context that has been ignored before. They stop volunteering for work that only leads to more work. They stop challenging weak decisions because the cost of honesty has become too high.

This is the silence leaders need to notice. Sometimes silence means people have stopped believing their voice will make a difference.

Why High Performers Burn Out Differently

High performers don’t always burn out in visible ways. Many continue functioning long after something inside them has become tired.

That is why burnout is often misunderstood in organisations.

We look for collapse, but before collapse there is usually a long period of adaptation.

A recent conversation on high-functioning burnout reminded me of this. Many people recognised the early signs because they often look like dedication from the outside: proving your worth, pushing your limits, neglecting your needs and normalising exhaustion.

The quiet signals leaders miss before high performers leave

These patterns are often rewarded before they’re recognised as warning signs.

One reader described burnout as spending too long adapting to conditions that were never sustainable. I thought about that for a long time because high performers are often very good at adapting. They adjust, absorb and keep moving until the cost becomes harder to ignore.

Sometimes the first signs of burnout don’t show up at work. They show up as less patience at home, neglected health, lost curiosity, withdrawal from people they love, or a quiet sense that they no longer feel like themselves.

This is one of the reasons I’ve been thinking so deeply about burnout while writing Burnout: A Human Story. Burnout is often described as exhaustion, but many people begin losing connection with themselves long before they stop functioning.

The Nuance Leaders Need to Hold

Not every resignation is a failure of leadership. Some people leave because they’ve outgrown the role. Some leave because their life has changed. Some leave because a new opportunity is genuinely right for them.

A good leader cannot and should not try to hold everyone forever. But there are also exits that could have been prevented much earlier, and those are the ones leaders need to pay closer attention to.

The goal is not to keep people at any cost. The goal is to build an environment where people don’t have to disconnect in order to protect themselves.

What Leaders Can Do Before People Disconnect

The first step is to notice change before it becomes a complaint. When someone who once contributed freely becomes quieter, don’t assume they’re simply busy. Ask what has changed for them.

When a high performer keeps receiving more work because they’re reliable, look honestly at whether their excellence is being rewarded with growth or only with more weight.

When someone’s ideas are repeatedly delayed, dismissed or taken over by others, pay attention to what that teaches them about speaking up.

When urgency becomes the normal rhythm of the organisation, ask whether the pace is truly necessary or whether the business has become used to operating without enough clarity.

Healthy leadership doesn’t require perfect conditions. It requires honest attention.

A leader can begin with better questions.

  • Are the same people always carrying the hardest work?
  • Are we giving our best people more opportunity or just more responsibility?
  • Do people feel safe enough to disagree before the decision is final?
  • Are we recognising effort in a way that feels meaningful?
  • Are we protecting recovery after intense seasons?
  • Are we blocking someone’s growth because their current performance is too useful
  • Are we fixing the system or depending on the same people to keep absorbing its gaps?

What leaders notice, they can begin to change.

When You Sense Someone Is Pulling Back

If a strong person on your team begins to withdraw, the first response should be curiosity, not defensiveness.

And it doesn’t have to begin as a formal performance conversation. In fact, the more useful conversation is a human one.

You can ask what has been feeling heavier than it should, where they feel blocked, what they’ve stopped raising because it hasn’t changed before, what would make the work more sustainable, or where they want to grow next.

The important part is what happens after the conversation. If someone is honest and nothing changes, the silence becomes deeper. If a leader listens and acts, trust has a chance to return.

The action doesn’t always have to be large. Sometimes it is redistributing work, clarifying priorities, creating a growth path, or protecting someone from becoming the permanent solution to a repeated problem.

Sometimes it is simply acknowledging what they’ve been carrying for too long.

Bringing Humanity Back Into Performance

Burnout is personal, but it is also shaped by the systems people live and work inside.

It lives in the way we define strength, reward over-functioning and mistake silence for stability. It also lives in the way people learn to appear fine while slowly losing connection with themselves.

This is the kind of conversation I hope Burnout: A Human Story will continue to open. The book is still taking shape, but the conversations around it are already reminding me why this work matters.

If this reflection resonates with you, I invite you to join the waitlist and become part of the community forming around the book.

High performers don’t need appreciation only after they leave. They need leaders who notice while they are still here. They need cultures where excellence isn’t quietly exploited, and where people can grow, speak, recover and contribute without disappearing into the weight of responsibility.

Sometimes, the first sign that a good person is leaving is not a resignation letter. It is the silence that came before it.

I would love to hear your perspective:

Which do you think leaders miss most often when high performers begin to disconnect: silence, frustration or loss of trust?

With clarity and intention,

Kiran Mann


Part of Harmony is Power, reflections on leadership, organizations and people from Kiran Mann, Founder of M2M Business Solutions Inc. A version of this piece first appeared on LinkedIn on Aug 4, 2026.

More from Harmony is Power  ·  Book an Executive Conversation  ·  Follow on LinkedIn